KCCI opposes rules empowering FBR to retrieve cash withdrawal information


KARACHI: Business community has resented the rules empowering Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to retrieve data of cash withdrawal from banking system.



Junaid Esmail Makda, President of the Karachi Chamber of Commerce & Industry (KCCI), strongly opposed the issuance of SRO 1305 (I)/ 2018 and stated that by giving access to account holders info under the said SRO, efforts being made for financial inclusion will be backtracked because it would encourage cash economy due to fear of harassment.

In a statement issued, Junaid Makda pointed out that under this SRO, FBR has prescribed a Cash Withdrawal Statement for banks to report information of persons who have withdrawn cash exceeding Rs50,000 in a day and taxes deduction thereon for filers and non-filers, aggregating to Rs1 million or more during the month.

“Instead of seeking information of both filers and non-filers, it would have been appropriate to seek information of non-filers only which would have encouraged non-filers to become filers, resulting in broadening the tax net of the country”, he added.

Referring to Karachi Chamber’s clear stance against the massive discretionary powers to FBR, President KCCI stated that the present government has assured from time to time that no harassment will be done either by FBR or FIA but such SROs may lead to further harassment to the masses, including the members of the business and industrial community.

He said, “As we firmly believe in legislations, the Karachi Chamber has always vocally opposed the SRO culture which has to be ended as it only paves way for harassment and corruption.”

“If given access to account holders’ details, more avenues of corruption will open where tax officials will start making under the table money by harassing people and businesses”, he added.

He urged the Ministry of Finance to withdraw the ‘draconian’ provisions and laws which have extended immense discretionary powers to the officers of Inland Revenue.

“We believe it is a core issue, resulting in loss of productivity and mental torture to the business community”, Junaid Makda said, “These laws have kept a large number of potential taxpayers out of the tax regime. In fact these laws are a deterrent to broadening of tax-net and have resulted in promoting the culture of tax-evasion.”

Copyright © Pakistan Revenue pkrevenue.com